The Elite Forum

The Big Three Plus One => GoldenEye 007 => Topic started by: AZ on March 01, 2013, 06:13:37 pm

Title: February 2013 Proof Call
Post by: AZ on March 01, 2013, 06:13:37 pm
Times that say NEEDS PROOF need videos up by April 1st or they will be backrolled.


Axel Zakrisson: Control Secret Agent 4:15 - PROVEN

David Clemens: Egypt Secret Agent 0:45 - PROVEN
Egypt 00 Agent 0:45 - PROVEN

David Witten: Bunker 2 Agent 0:24 - PROVEN

Gregor Degenhart: Runway Secret Agent 0:23 - PROVEN

Guilherme Alberto: Bunker 2 Agent 0:24 - PROVEN

Jim Barrett: Facility 00 Agent 0:56 - PROVEN

Jimmy Bauer: Facility Agent 0:45 - PROVEN
Caverns Secret Agent 1:23 - PROVEN
Caverns 00 Agent 1:38 - PROVEN

Karl Jobst: Bunker 1 Secret Agent 0:23 - PROVEN
Silo Agent 1:04 - PROVEN
Bunker 2 Agent 0:24 - PROVEN
Archives Secret Agent 0:54 - PROVEN

Luke Szklarz: Facility Agent 0:46 - PROVEN
Runway Agent 0:22 - PROVEN
Runway 00 Agent 0:39 - PROVEN
Silo Secret Agent 1:15 - PROVEN
Frigate Secret Agent 1:05 - PROVEN
Bunker 2 Agent 0:24 - PROVEN
Streets Agent 1:13 - PROVEN
Streets Secret Agent 1:56 - PROVEN
Streets 00 Agent 1:56 - PROVEN
Egypt Agent 0:47 - PROVEN

Rayan I.: Surface 1 00 Agent 1:48 - PROVEN
Silo 00 Agent 1:22 - PROVEN
Bunker 2 00 Agent 0:57 - PROVEN

Ryan Koch: Facility 00 Agent 0:56 - PROVEN
Bunker 1 00 Agent 1:09 - PROVEN
Bunker 2 Agent 0:24 - PROVEN
Bunker 2 00 Agent 1:07 - PROVEN

Ryan Lockwood: Silo Agent 1:03 - PROVEN

Ryan White: Bunker 2 Agent 0:24 - PROVEN
Jungle Agent 0:52 - PROVEN
Caverns Secret Agent 1:21 - PROVEN

Wouter Jansen: Bunker 2 Agent 0:24 - PROVEN


ALL times proven!!  :)


From the January Proof Call, Luke Szklarz's Control Agent 4:01 has been backrolled to 4:05 (insufficient video proof).
Title: Re: February 2013 Proof Call
Post by: RWG on March 01, 2013, 06:18:39 pm
LOL!  Then you might as well roll back Dam 1:16 / 1:55

Seriously Ax, just because you weren't proof mod when times were achieved, doesn't mean you can't proof call them NOW.  You're the proof moderator NOW.  They are your rankings.  You can call whatever you want.  Just because YE or Octo or Wouter or whoever, who didn't care at the time of being updater, didn't proof call a time... doesn't mean that the time belongs there.  It simply means they didn't care enough to proof call it.

You don't see the U.S. President "allow" something because a previous President allowed it.
Title: Re: February 2013 Proof Call
Post by: Darth Vader on March 01, 2013, 06:59:20 pm
Never gonna happen. Quote this.
Title: Re: February 2013 Proof Call
Post by: OHMSS on March 01, 2013, 08:22:41 pm
You see a judge "allow" something because a previous judge allowed it all the time.

Fixed it for you.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Precedent
Title: Re: February 2013 Proof Call
Post by: RWG on March 01, 2013, 08:30:05 pm
Lolling.  Lol bringing the legal system into this.  Legal systems around the world are consistently the most INCONSISTENT and CORRUPT systems we have.  A judge's word is so ridic.  He can have one day where he feels like being random, say something, and now it lasts forever and severely impacts someone's life.  Not to mention the lawyers, who are in fact PROFESSIONAL TROLLS simply trolling around trying to make up random bullshit, distracting the judge and the other side, in hopes his client can get away with whatever.

The guys like Matis, Marc, Jimbo, are the lawyers of this world, trolling around, acting like they are the EXCEPTIONS.  And the previous proof moderators are the LAZY JUDGES who didn't care and made bad decisions which are now permanent.

Good job everyone!
Title: Re: February 2013 Proof Call
Post by: flukey lukey on March 01, 2013, 08:56:43 pm
dick move rolling back 4:01, the video was sufficient proof for a shitty time imo. If it was 3:59 or 3:58 i could understand. I'll get 4:00 when I go back to control anyway, but for the time being I'm claiming 4:03 because it doesn't require proof.
Title: Re: February 2013 Proof Call
Post by: OHMSS on March 01, 2013, 09:45:47 pm
The end of your vid is more S1 fragments and blue screen than Control. And even besides those cuts, the quality is borderline horrible. Yes the Dam untied vids are bad quality, but they are like BluRay vs Atari compared to this Control vid.
It's a pity because there is no doubt you're capable of the claimed time and replaying a luck level sucks balls, but accepting that video as reasonable proof would be extremely lame, especially after the higher proof standards inflicted by the 2013 proof policy. Fair and proper decision by AxZ.

Ad Goose: I really don't wanna discuss justice and ethics right now.
Title: Re: February 2013 Proof Call
Post by: flukey lukey on March 01, 2013, 10:03:02 pm
I like the way it looks (ღ˘⌣˘ღ)
Title: Re: February 2013 Proof Call
Post by: SimThreat on March 01, 2013, 10:10:28 pm
LOL at thinking the 4:01 vid was sufficient. There was even some surface 1 half way through the run. The vid had me seriously lmfao at work. People were standing up and looking over at me because I was knocking shit over, and chocking on my own vomit I was laughing so hard. It was like I was have a seizure.

No one should accept a vid like that as proof. And claiming 4:03 is a massively dick move. It should be proof call and the level should be backrolled to 4:05 until better proof provided.
Title: Re: February 2013 Proof Call
Post by: AZ on March 01, 2013, 10:40:02 pm
LOL!  Then you might as well roll back Dam 1:16 / 1:55

Regarding this quote, I was gonna post something longer but OHMSS summed it up very good. I find it funny how you compare the 4:01 with Marc's Dam videos. Marc's original Egypt A 46 is more worthy of a comparison and that time/vid was also backrolled. We should strive for keeping those kind of videos to the minimum on our rankings, regardless of their (high) point value.

Luke is obviously a gifted player and easily capable of such a time, but this time he didn't provide sufficient proof for a claimed PR.

Quote
Seriously Ax, just because you weren't proof mod when times were achieved, doesn't mean you can't proof call them NOW.  You're the proof moderator NOW.  They are your rankings.  You can call whatever you want.  Just because YE or Octo or Wouter or whoever, who didn't care at the time of being updater, didn't proof call a time... doesn't mean that the time belongs there.  It simply means they didn't care enough to proof call it.

It's not my rankings. It's ours. the-elite's. What times do you want off the ranks so badly? I assume the ones you listed in your Proof Call topic? If that's the case, it's a pretty biased list (even half of those times have been proven or are proven). All I'm saying is that if those times should go, several others should, from a completely objective perspective, be backrolled as well. The list you provided in your topic is heavily biased and not very consistent.

I think it's ridic to require proof for just a handful of times you personally want to see proven.

edit: why not make a proven rankings? Perhaps YE could implement this into the current ranks or something.
Title: Re: February 2013 Proof Call
Post by: SimThreat on March 01, 2013, 10:51:00 pm
Obviously ryan doesn't actually want the times removed, he's just trying to make a point (a dumb one though). Why would you take him literally?
Title: Re: February 2013 Proof Call
Post by: RWG on March 01, 2013, 10:54:47 pm
FREE BUNKER 25s FOR EVERYONE !
Title: Re: February 2013 Proof Call
Post by: Darth Vader on March 02, 2013, 07:11:11 am
 :kappa:
Title: Re: February 2013 Proof Call
Post by: Shadow on March 04, 2013, 02:04:25 pm
Decided to watch the Control 4:01 to see what all the hoopla was about.

It was like having an out-of-body experience. I will never be the same again.