Ok lots to get through and a very slow espn site right now so ill be keeping this brief where possible. Probably lots of spellin mistakes but whatev.
Nates Losers
An aptly name team considering we have Beasley running all the way to the Elite 8 only to lose to Kansas, who are winning it all. Georgia beating Xavier is farcical
Best Pick: Texas CG
Worst Pick: Kansas State E8
Grade: C-
frantic 1
Pretty respectable bracket with a nice mixture of chances and bankers. I dont particularly like UCLA that much but mf has put this together ok.
Best Pick: Pitt S16
Worst Pick: Gonzaga 32
Grade: B+
Lark
A suprisingly safe and normal bracket from Lark. Was really expecting something appalling here.
Best Pick: Duke F4
Worst Pick: West Virginia 32
Grade: B
Ng's SuperBracket
Not too shabby. Again was really envisaging an atrocious set of selections. Texas winning it all is perhaps too over-exciting put I actually dont mind it.
Best Pick: Texas Win
Worst Pick: Saint Josephs 32
Grade: B+
IsThereAGrandTeam
This is a really mixed back. I like the gambles on texas and Pitt but HATE Arizona beating Drake in the E8. Some other odd selections early makes this a bizzare effort.
Best Pick: Pitt E8
Worst Pick: Arizona F4
Grade: D+
Octo's Madness!
Standard North Carolina over UCLA in the final, but Im really struggling to get past Davidson beating Georgetown early.
Best Pick: Pitt E8
Worst Pick: Davidson S16
Grade: B
NOAKEVBO
Wow this is actually a really great offering. Perhaps hurt by too much conservatism in the early rounds, but otherise very solid.
Best Pick: Gtown F4
Worst Pick: West Virginia 32
Grade: A-
packattackUWgotscrewed
Automatic D for all four #1 seeds in the final 4. Really you need to be more imaginative!
Best Pick: Louisville E8
Worst Pick: Butler S16
Grade: D
MMF winning bracket
Another ridiculous bracket with all four #1 seeds making it and very little interesting going on before that.
Best Pick: Arizona 32
Worst Pick: Wisconsin E8
Grade: D-
Dayle's Losers!
Alright, if i see a bracket worse than this feel free to shoot me. I dont know where to start. Is there even ONE #1 seed in the elite 8? Kent St in the F4???? Notre Dame in the championship game???? Connecticut winning it??????????? PLAYOFFS???
Best Pick: Wisconsin E8
Worst Pick: Kent St F4
Grade: F
hovis 1
Some good and bad here - mostly bad. I dont like Memphis to win at all, and both Tennessee and Louisville losing in 32 isnt fun. Nevertheless there is some good imagination and the upsets are somewhat possible - but that many of them?
Best Pick: Purdue S16
Worst Pick: Memphis winner
Grade: C
QB's Cookie Cutter
Look, Im having to sit here grading like 50 brackets and I just dont have time for this kind of nonsense. All 4 #1 seeds in final four?? This thing is so devoid of upsets its ridiculous.
Best Pick: Pitt S16
Worst Pick: Stanford E8
Grade: D
Cyber's picks
The top half of this is ok and then you scroll down and see Davidson and West Virginia in the S16. Lots of Kansas fans in the Elite.
Best Pick: Pitt F4
Worst Pick: South Alabama 32
Grade: C
Matt8000 ftw
Youd figure this would be as bad as Dayles, however its actually alright. Some possible upsets in there that are reasonable although perhaps too much of a stretch.
Best Pick: Tennessee F4
Worst Pick: Wisconsin CG
Grade: B-
Come's Sheet of Integrity
This is fairly average attempt. I like the way its balanced but I just feel that some of the wrong choices were made in terms of the matchups in the Elite 8. Since its a genuine sheet of integrity ill give it a stronger grade than I would were this from someone like Jon.
Best Pick: Pitt F4
Worst Pick: UCLA Win
Grade: B+
Dykstra 1
Marquette in E8 seems a little implausible, but ill give some credit for tempering the desire to push them past Memphis. The Davidson love is silly though
Best Pick: Louisville F4
Worst Pick: Davidson S16
Grade: B-
mikerspd MADnessest
This isnt so bad. I disagree with some of the selections but I can see where its coming from. I dont really like UCLA making the championship game but Id favour them over Memphis at least.
Best Pick: Wisconsin F4
Worst Pick: South Alabama 32
Grade: B+
Topes
Hmm some early upsets make this a weird bracket to look at. Butler, USC and BYu all in the E8? I think thats being way too optimistic!
Best Pick: Texas F4
Worst Pick: BYU E8
Grade: C
Kessler 1
Alright another chump with all four #1 seeds in the F4. Not only that but we have 3 #2 and 1 #3 in the E8. And its the WRONG #3 to pick out of all of them too. You really need to pull yourself together!
Best Pick: UNC Win
Worst Pick: Memphis CG
Grade: D-
Wiff's lucky picks
This would have been a decent bracket but for some silly stuff in the early rounds. I enjoyed George Masons performances better in 24. Basketball just isnt his thing. And Duke winning it?
Best Pick: Texas F4
Worst Pick: George Mason 32
Grade: c+
wheatrich's invitational
This is a really really disappoinign effort. It looks pretty near the end but the first 3 rounds are just horrible and wheat will be way out of contention before this has even started.
Best Pick: Texas CG
Worst Pick: South Alabama S16
Grade: D
darthrob64
If theres any bracket here for which the predicted points of 1680 is accurate, its this one. Top to bottom this is probably the most astute submission with the perfect blend of favourites progressing and upsets. Theres no doubt had this bracket been available for others in the 'Copy Picks' box that a lot of people would have been hard pressed to pass up the opportunity to benefit from the wonderful insight on display here.
Best Pick: Duke F4
Worst Pick: UCLA E8
Grade: A
AnderssonBallers
Ok Axel knows absolutely nothing about college basketball but I actually dont mind his bracket. The Gonzaga, Oklahoma and Oral Roberts stuff is a little excessive
Best Pick: Tennesee CG
Worst Pick: Stanford F4
Grade: B
wtf...is this basketball?
Wtf... is this a serious bracket? Ok its not quite as bad as Dayles but is getting there. Marquette in the final? Indiana, Baylor and Davidson in the E8? God at least Kansas are winning it.
Best Pick: Kansas win
Worst Pick: Oral Roberts E8
Grade: F+
Thira's Ownage
You know what, theres a lot of off the wall stuff in here but I like the way its been applied. This is a bracket that could actually win it all in an odd kind of way.
Best Pick: Clemson E8
Worst Pick: Winthrop 32
Grade: A-
*Whoooooooooooosh*
Not a lot of Gtown love in the Elite it seems. This would have been a nice bracket but them Mississippi went and ruined it. Kentucky to S16 is a stretch.
Best Pick: Gtown F4
Worst Pick: Mississippi St F4
Grade: C+
D12
Another four #1 seeds chump. And some silly early upsets too. Get it together guys!
Best Pick: Butler E8
Worst Pick: Boise State S16
Grade: D
BrewCity Bracket
This is ok. Im kinda seeing the same bracket a lot now. Its nicely balanced though. Could do well.
Best Pick: Pitt F4
Worst Pick: UCLA winner
Grade: B+
Elite's Worst Bracket
Wow he wasnt kidding. Gonzaga to the F4? Vanderbilt to the E8? Connecticut to the finals? Anyone finishing below this seabracket really is a complete loser.
Best Pick: UNC win
Worst Pick: Gonzaga E8
Grade: C-
Lavery 1
Cry. Why....why???? Out of all the teams in the lower half of the East you pick St Josephs to make it to the E8? This bracket is just beyond hope.
Best Pick: UNC Win
Worst Pick: UNLV S16
Grade: E
Goose
Yet another four #1 seeder. CMON GUYS. Use your knowledge properly. Stretch your brains! YOu can do it! (next year)
Best Pick: Pitt S16
Worst Pick: Marquette E8
Grade: D
Woll
THis is alright. Xavier love a bit too far but a reaonable blend of the sublime and the ridiculous. Could be a dark horse
Best Pick: Wisconsin F4
Worst Pick: Xavier CG
Grade: B+
Saw DKK at a lemonparty
I dont know whats worse here. St Marys in the E8 or Belmont in the S16. Actually back the fun bus up. American over Tennessee? Ill grad up just because that made me lol.
Best Pick: American 32
Worst Pick: Belmont S16
Grade: B
OD Wins
Really poor selection here packed full of all the wrong upsets and a comical choice of winner. I dont know what they put in those dog biscuits. oh wait..
Best Pick: Louisville F4
Worst Pick: Wisconsin winner
Grade: D+
Poteau Jedi
This is nates second bracket and probably the stronger of the two.
Best Pick: Kansas State not in E8
Worst Pick: Texas not in CG
Grade: B-
Kingers Perfect Picks
DING. So someone did use copy picks? Wow this is what Im talking about right here! In it to win it PDO!
Best Pick: Villanova S16
Worst Pick: Oklahoma S16
Grade: A-
Mike 1
This was ok i suppose. South kinda ruins it a bit but it has potential to do well.
Best Pick: Butler S16
Worst Pick: Stanford F4
Grade: B
PSK
Shoot me now. THREE #1 seeds being kicked off by #16s? And the one making it through Memphis?? Are you kidding me? Miami winning it all? Are there enough letters in the alphabet? This might be an elite first grade!
Best Pick: Drake F4
Worst Pick: American E8
Grade: G
PYLemire
I really dont like some of the early upsets and Butler to F4 seems too much
Best Pick: Kansas CG
Worst Pick: Cornell S16
Grade: C-
jon forced me to do this
Next time Jon needs to keep his mouth shut so I dont have to put up with horrible entries like this. i dont think theres actually a single lower seed win here other than a couple of first round #9s. Pure fantasy
Best Pick: NC Win
Worst Pick: UCLA CG
Grade: E
MisterGuru
This isnt as bad as it first looked to me. I can go with this to some extent although taking Wisconsin to the championship game was perhaps too much.
Best Pick: Texas win
Worst Pick: South Alabama 32
Grade: B
Boss
This is a reasonably well put together bracket that does have some potential to succeed. I like the thread thats been woven here and dare I say another dark horse.
Best Pick: Tennessee win
Worst Pick: West virginia 32
Grade: B+