Author Topic: August 2018 Proof Call  (Read 893 times)

mw

  • Moderator
  • Posts: 240
    • GE
    • PD
    • twitch
August 2018 Proof Call
« on: September 01, 2018, 02:12:14 am »
Times that say NEEDS PROOF need videos up by October 1st or they will be backrolled.
Also included are the point values, and whether the time was a TWR or UWR when listed time was achieved.

Alka Maass
Investigation Agent 1:10 (94 points) - PROVEN
Defection Special Agent 0:23 (90 points) - PROVEN
Total Points Gained: 8

Antler
Infiltration Agent 1:12 (79 points) - PROVEN
Crash Site Special Agent 1:31 (73 points) - PROVEN
Infiltration Special Agent 1:44 (62 points) - PROVEN
CI Agent 0:52 (72 points) - PROVEN
Total Points Gained: 223

aperturegrillz
MBR Agent 1:20 (64 points) - PROVEN
Total Points Gained: 64

DuskyLW
Infiltration Agent 1:11 (94 points) - PROVEN
Total Points Gained: 14

FOrK
Rescue Special Agent 2:24 (60 points) - PROVEN
Pelagic II Agent 0:50 (69 points) - PROVEN
Rescue Agent 1:30 (60 points) - PROVEN
Air Force One Agent 0:54 (85 points) - PROVEN
Air Force One Special Agent 1:23 (67 points) - PROVEN
Escape Perfect Agent 3:42 (67 points) - PROVEN
Escape Special Agent 3:29 (71 points) - PROVEN
Total Points Gained: 62

Greenounet
Pelagic II Perfect Agent 2:01 (90 points) - PROVEN
Pelagic II Special Agent 1:43 (91 points) - PROVEN
Total Points Gained: 6

Icy
MBR Perfect Agent 1:08 (91 points) - PROVEN
MBR Special Agent 0:59 (91 points) - PROVEN
MBR Agent 1:00 (91 points) - PROVEN
Extraction Perfect Agent 1:37 (89 points) - PROVEN
Extraction Special Agent 1:29 (90 points) - PROVEN
Extraction Agent 0:50 (87 points) - PROVEN
Air Base Perfect Agent 2:06 (88 points) - PROVEN
Air Base Special Agent 1:44 (91 points) - PROVEN
Air Base Agent 1:14 (93 points) - PROVEN
Total Points Gained: 39

KevinDDR
Villa Perfect Agent 1:40 (75 points) - NEEDS PROOF
Pelagic II Agent 0:48 (75 points) - PROVEN
Infiltration Special Agent 1:39 (78 points) - PROVEN
Infiltration Agent 1:13 (63 points) - PROVEN
Air Force One Perfect Agent 1:27 (92 points) - PROVEN
Air Force One Agent 0:52 (TWR) - PROVEN
Defection Agent 0:06 (85 points) - PROVEN
Chicago Agent 0:15 (97 points) - PROVEN
Total Points Gained: 188

Lake Demon
Villa Perfect Agent 1:38 (84 points) - PROVEN
Villa Special Agent 1:20 (87 points) - PROVEN
G5 Special Agent 0:44 (90 points) - PROVEN
G5 Perfect Agent 0:57 (87 points) - PROVEN
Extraction Special Agent 1:30 (87 points) - PROVEN
Extraction Perfect Agent 1:37 (89 points) - PROVEN
Infiltration Special Agent 1:35 (88 points) - PROVEN
Rescue Special Agent 2:22 (78 points) - NEEDS PROOF
Rescue Agent 1:26 (92 points) - PROVEN
Pelagic II Agent 0:47 (79 points) - PROVEN
Rescue Perfect Agent 3:00 (72 points) - PROVEN
Air Base Perfect Agent 2:07 (86 points) - PROVEN
Air Base Special Agent 1:44 (91 points) - PROVEN
Air Base Agent 1:14 (93 points) - PROVEN
Chicago Perfect Agent 0:28 (84 points) - PROVEN
Air Force One Perfect Agent 1:28 (86 points) - PROVEN
WAR! Special Agent 0:49 (69 points) - PROVEN
WAR! Perfect Agent 0:58 (72 points) - PROVEN
Total Points Gained: 222

MW
WAR! Agent 0:26 (83 points) - PROVEN
Total Points Gained: 24

Pauliwood
G5 Agent 0:43 (60 points) - PROVEN
Air Base Special Agent 1:47 (69 points) - PROVEN
Air Base Agent 1:16 (73 points) - PROVEN
Rescue Agent 1:29 (67 points) - PROVEN
Maian SOS Perfect Agent 2:18 (60 points) - PROVEN
Maian SOS Special Agent 2:01 (61 points) - PROVEN
Rescue Special Agent 2:23 (70 points) - PROVEN
Air Base Perfect Agent 2:14 (77 points) - PROVEN
Air Force One Agent 0:56 (64 points) - PROVEN
Rescue Perfect Agent 2:59 (73 points) - PROVEN
Total Points Gained: 190

PunJaB
Pelagic II Perfect Agent 2:13 (83 points) - PROVEN
Pelagic II Special Agent 1:53 (73 points) - PROVEN
Villa Perfect Agent 1:40 (76 points) - PROVEN
Crash Site Agent 1:18 (77 points) - PROVEN
Crash Site Special Agent 1:30 (77 points) - PROVEN
Escape Special Agent 3:27 (77 points) - NEEDS BETTER PROOF, VIDEO IS CROPPED
Air Force One Perfect Agent 1:28 (86 points) - PROVEN
Villa Agent 1:10 (73 points) - NEEDS BETTER PROOF, VIDEO IS 240p
WAR! Perfect Agent 0:59 (63 points) - NEEDS BETTER PROOF, VIDEO IS 240p
Total Points Gained: 237

Sam Fisher
CI Agent 0:53 (67 points) - PROVEN
Total Points Gained: 25

SGT RAGEQUIT
Maian SOS Special Agent 1:54 (90 points) - PROVEN
Total Points Gained: 9

speedruntrainer
Defection Special Agent 0:25 (86 points) - PROVEN
Total Points Gained: 5

Swiss
WAR! Agent 0:25 (TWR) - PROVEN
Total Points Gained: 16

----------------------------------------------------

From last month's Proof Call:

Homieonice
Pelagic II Special Agent 1:44 backrolled to 1:50 (No Proof)

Wodahs-Reklaw
Extraction Agent 0:51 backrolled to 0:52 (Insufficient Proof)

Zachary Risebrough
Entire PD timespage backrolled to N/A (Failure to provide proof for the requested times)

----------------------------------------------------

2 TWRs achieved last month!
0 UWRs achieved last month!

This month's Player Of The Month is awarded to PunJaB with 237 points gained last month!
This month's Outstanding Players are awarded to KevinDDR, and Swiss who both achieved 1 TWR last month!
This month's Dunce Of The Month is awarded to PunJaB. Keep up the GREAT proof standards mate.  :nesquik:
PD Proof Moderator

flicker

  • Posts: 1445
  • Shadows of the Empire N64 World Champion
    • Flickerform
    • GE
    • PD
    • twitch
    • 2016RankingsDev
    • 2017RankingsDev
Re: August 2018 Proof Call
« Reply #1 on: September 01, 2018, 05:12:01 am »
PD LTK

Flickerform
Investigation DLTK 4:18 (Untied!) - PROVEN
Investigation DLTK 4:15 (Untied!) - PROVEN
WAR! LTK 0:52 (Untied!) - PROVEN

Big Bossman
Investigation LTK 2:57 (Untied!) - PROVEN

Pauliwood
Duel LTK 0:09 (TWR) - PROVEN
Rescue LTK 4:32 (90 points) - PROVEN
Rescue DLTK 5:20 (93 points) - PROVEN

MadmanFlechr
Duel LTK 0:09 (TWR) - PROVEN

Icy
MBR LTK 1:08 (97 points) - PROVEN
MBR DLTK 1:11 (95 points) - PROVEN

Backrolls:
Lake Demon
Deep Sea LTK 3:49 to N/A
Chicago LTK 0:36 to N/A
Air Base LTK 2:54 to N/A
« Last Edit: September 01, 2018, 03:45:35 pm by flicker »

Procrastinator

  • Posts: 14
  • Lake Demon
    • GE
    • PD
    • twitch
Re: August 2018 Proof Call
« Reply #2 on: September 01, 2018, 01:33:54 pm »
Luke’s G5 sa 45 and Crash Site sa 132 haven’t been backrolled yet.

mw

  • Moderator
  • Posts: 240
    • GE
    • PD
    • twitch
Re: August 2018 Proof Call
« Reply #3 on: September 01, 2018, 03:12:27 pm »
Luke’s G5 sa 45 and Crash Site sa 132 haven’t been backrolled yet.

Thanks, I'm honestly not sure what happened. I guess I forgot to backroll things at the July Proof Call.

From June's Proof Call:

Homieonice
Extraction Agent 0:50 backrolled to 0:51
Crash Site SA 1:32 backrolled to 1:38
G5 SA 0:45 backrolled to 0:47

xxomg
MBR Agent 1:20 backrolled to 1:26
PD Proof Moderator

Selenium Webdriver

  • Posts: 3868
    • Ace
    • 2017RankingsDev
    • 2017CommunityContributor
Re: August 2018 Proof Call
« Reply #4 on: September 01, 2018, 03:28:51 pm »
Could be worth integrating into the software. Just pretty rare to see records actually get backrolled.

punjabie

  • Posts: 102
    • GE
    • PD
Re: August 2018 Proof Call
« Reply #5 on: September 02, 2018, 01:34:25 am »
Ok I must protest honestly. If I get back rolled here I will be very upset. You can clearly see the timer counting and I dont know why my escape sa vid has that weird croppy look to it but its not cropped. It was just my obs being a cunt for a bit until I fixed it. So it is not centered is all. You can see the entire screen of the run however and should not change I thing as far as it being proven is concerned. As far as youtube uploading a couple of my videos in 240p that is out of mu control and shouldnt be subject to back rolled. Again you can see the mission timer counting clear as day and thus the proof is more than adequate. Please feel free to responed with any concerns but if Im forced to dupe these times over this I will be very pissed. Please and thank you

Alec M.

  • Posts: 2651
  • TroubleClef92
    • GE
    • PD
    • twitch
    • 2016RankingsDev
Re: August 2018 Proof Call
« Reply #6 on: September 02, 2018, 01:49:53 am »
Ok I must protest honestly. If I get back rolled here I will be very upset. You can clearly see the timer counting and I dont know why my escape sa vid has that weird croppy look to it but its not cropped. It was just my obs being a cunt for a bit until I fixed it. So it is not centered is all. You can see the entire screen of the run however and should not change I thing as far as it being proven is concerned. As far as youtube uploading a couple of my videos in 240p that is out of mu control and shouldnt be subject to back rolled. Again you can see the mission timer counting clear as day and thus the proof is more than adequate. Please feel free to responed with any concerns but if Im forced to dupe these times over this I will be very pissed. Please and thank you

Why not re-record your footage into acceptable quality? There are settings you can change. Upscale it, ensure nothign is cropped in the outcome, etc.
"Train smarter, not harder" -Mike O'Hearn
GoldenEye Proof Moderator as of February 2015

punjabie

  • Posts: 102
    • GE
    • PD
Re: August 2018 Proof Call
« Reply #7 on: September 02, 2018, 01:55:18 am »
I dont actually know how to do that. And I dont have any of the original videos because I was having hard drive issues (main reason I think thos last few runs turned out the way they did) until I put in my new hard drive and everything went back to normal. But if someone could help me with getting the quality up on those vids I would be most appreciative.

mw

  • Moderator
  • Posts: 240
    • GE
    • PD
    • twitch
Re: August 2018 Proof Call
« Reply #8 on: September 02, 2018, 02:27:23 am »
Ok I must protest honestly. If I get back rolled here I will be very upset. You can clearly see the timer counting and I dont know why my escape sa vid has that weird croppy look to it but its not cropped. It was just my obs being a cunt for a bit until I fixed it. So it is not centered is all. You can see the entire screen of the run however and should not change I thing as far as it being proven is concerned. As far as youtube uploading a couple of my videos in 240p that is out of mu control and shouldnt be subject to back rolled. Again you can see the mission timer counting clear as day and thus the proof is more than adequate. Please feel free to responed with any concerns but if Im forced to dupe these times over this I will be very pissed. Please and thank you

Just following the proof policy to the letter here mate.

Quote
No apparent cropping of the video exists

The Escape video is very apparently cropped, and if you don't believe me then measure the number of pixels from the timer to the bottom of the screen compared to a normal run. It looks like you accidentally dragged the game feed downwards in your OBS window or something. It may be minor, but I'm forced to not accept it. In fact, I had debated looking more closely at your P2 SA, P2 PA, Villa PA, CS A, and CS SA as well because they do not include the familiar black bars across the top and bottom of the screen, so they may technically be cropped, but I decided that was a bit too much to ask from you. If I were even more of a stickler for rules you might be looking at a lot more times to reprove.

Quote
Video resolution is at least 360p

The videos are uploaded in 240p, and policy dictates that this is unacceptable. Sure, I can see the timer incrementing, but that's not the only reason we have a resolution standard. Also, I can't actually read the timer, so how is that "more than adequate" proof? If you think the quality is fine, redownload the videos and upscale/reupload them in 360p, and I'll give you a judgement.

I dont actually know how to do that.

You have a month to learn.
PD Proof Moderator

punjabie

  • Posts: 102
    • GE
    • PD
Re: August 2018 Proof Call
« Reply #9 on: September 02, 2018, 08:13:50 am »
The p2 vids and so on are definitely legit. I have the window in my obs set to where you wont have those black bars on top or bottom, but ill revert the red box to the size of the obs window just to be safe from now on. The escape vid however was recorded that way because as you mentioned it was pulled down on obs when I recorded it so its forever fucked. I feel like I should get the one warning pass Irie got on his b2 but that can be up to you and counsel to decide and what not. I need to improve said time anyway so extra motivation I guess. As for villa and war however they have been up scaled and re uploaded. Let me know if there is anything else I must do. Thanks
« Last Edit: September 02, 2018, 08:24:57 am by Punjabie »

mw

  • Moderator
  • Posts: 240
    • GE
    • PD
    • twitch
Re: August 2018 Proof Call
« Reply #10 on: September 02, 2018, 11:22:50 am »
Alright I'll give you a warning. Just don't do it again.  :nesquik:
PD Proof Moderator

punjabie

  • Posts: 102
    • GE
    • PD
Re: August 2018 Proof Call
« Reply #11 on: September 02, 2018, 12:19:20 pm »
lol thank you sir  :nesquik: And yes I have been agonizing over all my resolution settings to ensure nothing like this ever transpires again. Duping tough times is not something I enjoy.

flicker

  • Posts: 1445
  • Shadows of the Empire N64 World Champion
    • Flickerform
    • GE
    • PD
    • twitch
    • 2016RankingsDev
    • 2017RankingsDev
Re: August 2018 Proof Call
« Reply #12 on: September 06, 2018, 10:34:45 pm »
proof call for deep sea agent NTSC-J version untied tbh

mw

  • Moderator
  • Posts: 240
    • GE
    • PD
    • twitch
Re: August 2018 Proof Call
« Reply #13 on: September 07, 2018, 01:06:39 am »
proof call for deep sea agent NTSC-J version untied tbh

Yeah that's a good idea. ATTN Pauliwood, prove Deep Sea A 3:17 or better on Jap in the next month, and an extra week because of how late this was added.

As a general rule I will not be proof calling version untieds if someone has proof of a better or equal time on a different version, unless those two versions are significantly different (like Deep Sea for example). This is why I never bothered uploading proof for my MBR A/SA Jap version untieds, and I don't even have the vids anymore.
PD Proof Moderator

flicker

  • Posts: 1445
  • Shadows of the Empire N64 World Champion
    • Flickerform
    • GE
    • PD
    • twitch
    • 2016RankingsDev
    • 2017RankingsDev
Re: August 2018 Proof Call
« Reply #14 on: September 07, 2018, 01:49:00 am »
for reference, the previous record was my 3:29, and pauli also posted a 3:21, so in the case of a backroll it would go back to 3:33

edit: speedruntrainer posted a 3:19 on deep sea agent jap back in nov 2017 and it is also unproven :ohwell:
« Last Edit: September 07, 2018, 06:00:11 am by flicker »

Pauliwood

  • Posts: 14
Re: August 2018 Proof Call
« Reply #15 on: September 07, 2018, 11:59:39 pm »